अंधेरा

Bohemian Rhapsody's Terrible Editing - A Breakdown

Thomas Flight
सदस्यता लें
दृश्य 1 580 620
91% 34 351 2 994

Use my link www.audible.com/thomasflight or text THOMASFLIGHT to 500-500 to get a free Audiobook, two Audible Originals, and a 30-day free trial.
Bohemian Rhapsody won the Oscar for Best Editing... but it has terrible editing.
// My patreon: www.patreon.com/thomasflight
// Music licensed from Musicbed: share.mscbd.fm/thomasflight
// TWITTER: twitter.com/thomasflight
// WEBSITE: www.thomasflight.com
// FACEBOOK: facebook.com/thomasflight
// I edit my videos using Premiere Pro: amzn.to/2FJwU2u
// For Sponsorship and Business inquiries: me@thomasflight.com

फ़िल्म और ऐनिमेशन

 

14/03/2019

शेयर करें:

शेयर करें:

वीडियो डाउनलोड करें:

लिंक लोड हो रहा है.....

में जोड़े:

मेरी संगीतसूची
बाद में देखना
टिप्पणियाँ 3 115
Cal Studios
Cal Studios घंटे पहले
The ad that played before this had a Queen song in it
VeganRevolution
VeganRevolution घंटे पहले
Great breakdown thanks
even now, still i think
even now, still i think 2 घंटे पहले
bohemian rhapsody, from the very start, was more of an attempt to appeal to wrong generation redditors than people who are actually interested in the story of queen
Subzero
Subzero 2 घंटे पहले
And i thought i was stupid thinking the editing was so bad 😂
yosoyalbertico
yosoyalbertico 2 घंटे पहले
Totally agree
Mau365PP
Mau365PP 2 घंटे पहले
I haven't notice this until I saw this video
Erica Simpson
Erica Simpson 2 घंटे पहले
Why is jarring bad? What if the discontinuity was a creative choice?
rypulliam
rypulliam 2 घंटे पहले
There were so many damn montages in this movie I could not believe that it got nominated in the first place and then I came to discover that Bryan Singer is the director AKA sexual predator so then on top of that it just made me like the movie even less although Rami Malek did deliver a really good performance.
Gemma Sutton
Gemma Sutton 3 घंटे पहले
I didn’t notice this when I watched it but now i can’t unsee it
HD Pirat
HD Pirat 3 घंटे पहले
I rlly like this movie, I like it a lot tbh. But I did notice the edits and their abundance
reuben champion
reuben champion 3 घंटे पहले
The pacing for that first scene you talk about is to make you feel awkward and uncomfortable. So they work great for the intended purpose.
Brown Boy
Brown Boy 3 घंटे पहले
oscar milgya use ab apni gaand mraate rho
Roxane
Roxane 3 घंटे पहले
The editing is flawed but I feel like some people totally overract about it...having a seizure every scene...lol you did not like it, it's fine but stop being so dramatic and over the top. It would not have been that popular if it was so unwatchable 🙄 I know many people who watched in several times in cinema.
sober leech
sober leech 4 घंटे पहले
So many great points and very well put together (unlike this overrated crap we're discussing here; also, editing is not the only problem here, far from it). My respect.
Rees Cullen
Rees Cullen 4 घंटे पहले
Just because they change the view doesn’t make it bad editing even if it is quite constant
Austin G.
Austin G. 4 घंटे पहले
I'm glad I'm not the only one who thought the pacing was insanely bad until the part where Mary calls Freddie out for his sexuality. Then it kind of stabilizes from there somewhat, but the first 30 minutes are just campy and overly dramatic without any real emotional gravity to go with it until the aforementioned scene. It's almost like watching two different movies. It views kind of like "this happened, and then this happened, and then this happened, and then this happened, and then this happened", and then it slows down a bit and packs more of a punch. Overall, it was a good (albeit inaccurate) movie.
flowertales
flowertales 4 घंटे पहले
this scene gives me motion sickness... i wish i were kidding
Knox Productions
Knox Productions 4 घंटे पहले
So in your professional opinion as a leading, experienced, skilled editor, you think it's bad editing. Actually you've just made a statement, a hard statement of fact, not an opinion. But it won one of the most prestigious awards for editing! And everything you learned about the 'rules' of editing from film school and late night google holes about how best to make a film is broken and not used. Why? Because art doesn't follow your rules. How many rules of film-making does Pulp Fiction follow? Because it broke them all at the time. AND the editor did it without a director. I hope one day people realise your brilliance as a 'visual essay writer' and subsequently judge art based on your opinion.
some short asian
some short asian 5 घंटे पहले
y can't ppl just enjoy movies anymore? y pick it apart sm that ppl that like it resent it. and honestly-none of this stuff stood out to me that much so...
Buuzzsaw Touched Me
Buuzzsaw Touched Me 5 घंटे पहले
I thought the timeline for this film was all wrong. Because if your a Die Hard Queen like (such as myself) you keep on expecting certain events to happen, where they don't. An alternatively if your just the Casual fan (which is who this film was made for) due to what was missing from the film, I can see why it would confuse them too (such as Freddie's realisation of being Gay/Bi and/or the development of his relationship with Jim Hutton, as with Jim Hutton your never sure whether they are/aren't together). Then most importantly, music wise it doesn't show the climb they went through pre-1st album, as Freddie just randomly says in the film while fixing the Van "let's sell the Van and use that money to record an album", an it just doesn't work like that (maybe these days, but not back then).
BJ EV
BJ EV 6 घंटे पहले
Terribly good jajajaja
RACine Filmagens - Films & Videos
RACine Filmagens - Films & Videos 6 घंटे पहले
Talk is cheap.
Edgy
Edgy 6 घंटे पहले
I liked this scene but I also know nothing about editing so take this as someone who knows nothing about music saying they like modern pop music.
TheJaybrone
TheJaybrone 6 घंटे पहले
I think the editing issues came in large part due to a director that basically disappeared as the movie was close to wrapping. But it is definitely not well edited and had 0 business winning for it.
Itami Kuroitsuki
Itami Kuroitsuki 6 घंटे पहले
sO ThIS iS QuEen ?
Shawn DeJesus
Shawn DeJesus 6 घंटे पहले
Academy Awards have to be a joke by now.
keyda castaño
keyda castaño 7 घंटे पहले
This movie won vedt musical editing
Quipt Training
Quipt Training 7 घंटे पहले
Lol I was just about to bring up the transformers movies, they make cuts every 2 seconds and it triggers my anxiety.
Caroline Klemensová
Caroline Klemensová 7 घंटे पहले
I'm way far from being a film critic but even I noticed the bad editing when watching this movie..
FineCrafters
FineCrafters 7 घंटे पहले
Why can’t people just appreciate this film for who it’s about
Mr Me
Mr Me 7 घंटे पहले
Blah blah blah the movie was great. Find something better to make videos about pedantic dude.
Cassandre Cendre
Cassandre Cendre 7 घंटे पहले
A movie for those who discovered Queen in 2018.
Chuck Buskee
Chuck Buskee 8 घंटे पहले
I think it won because all of those transition cuts into a song or performance scene, those were pretty cool. But yeah, in general the editing was pure shit.
John Baumgartner
John Baumgartner 8 घंटे पहले
Quick aside, Walter Murch was not the editor of GODFATHER, though he had a big influence on the sound design
Aesthetical Twat
Aesthetical Twat 9 घंटे पहले
I was happy watching it, and that’s the most important thing.
Ema With A Tee
Ema With A Tee 9 घंटे पहले
Watching the scenes cut is like being hit by a hammer while also having whiplash. Maybe it's just because I'm tired, but it's almost impossible to watch
Cahal Doherty
Cahal Doherty 10 घंटे पहले
great film guy was tiny compared to freddy thk like really jarred me
SANTA IS AMAZING MUGHEAD
SANTA IS AMAZING MUGHEAD 10 घंटे पहले
Actually that doesn’t bother that much you said .
tequilex rook
tequilex rook 10 घंटे पहले
I'm feeling dizzy right now after watching this
A Conneely
A Conneely 10 घंटे पहले
If I get your Free Audiobook will I learn how to win an Oscar ?
Im Bored
Im Bored 10 घंटे पहले
yeah the bad editing is incredibly clear in the climax of the film, where the music drops the camera will have anti climatic shots like a side view of rami or of the crowd
wesley Phillip
wesley Phillip 12 घंटे पहले
gr8; my FB comment was that the film is an overblown video ... however I don't think it was aimed at people like me (60+).
AJ King
AJ King 12 घंटे पहले
Paid by the cut!
Tommy Nico
Tommy Nico 13 घंटे पहले
I seriously don't understand why it got so many accolades. As you stated the editing is quite poor in places but I found some of the acting and dialogue just absolutely dreadful. It's so cringe in places. Rami Malek was great....however everything else wasn't. It's infuriating when people say it's one of the greatest films of the last 10-20 years. I mean come on.
Heven demo
Heven demo 13 घंटे पहले
Is it weird that I find that it fits the image of queen because its unconventional like they were?
宋少閑 。
宋少閑 。 13 घंटे पहले
A great film with tons of cuts that won best editing is JFK
Frost Byte
Frost Byte 14 घंटे पहले
9:57 Hits the uncanny valley for me, look like cgi
jules giddings
jules giddings 14 घंटे पहले
If the editing was so bad, why did the editor get an oscar?
Ryan C. Reed
Ryan C. Reed 16 घंटे पहले
Was stylized this way on purpose. The fact that you made this video is proof you’ve missed the point entirely. It’s why you’re making IN-vid videos instead of feature films earning Oscars.
Loga Padmanaba
Loga Padmanaba 16 घंटे पहले
I had felt that something was off in this scene. It's good to know what actually it was...
Mtwarrior
Mtwarrior 17 घंटे पहले
so this is queen
markdabomb 64
markdabomb 64 17 घंटे पहले
The John Reid scene should of been that when he says "So, this is Queen" We should of got a shot of the whole band then an individual shot of each member This would of given them equal credit of being a member
Daisy B
Daisy B 18 घंटे पहले
Idk if this is because I'm a huge queen stan and like soooo far up each of the BoRhap boys arses but I never really realised the editing lmao, I guess it just comes down to preferences?¿
Grr Kpp
Grr Kpp 18 घंटे पहले
Good perspective
Grr Kpp
Grr Kpp 18 घंटे पहले
Wtf!
Wynner3
Wynner3 19 घंटे पहले
Was this edited by the same people who did Suicide Squad? That was horrendous and made it hard to sit through the movie. So glad I didn't see this movie as I'm sure I would have been equally disappointed.
Death In The Spotlight
Death In The Spotlight 19 घंटे पहले
One of the most overrated movies of recent memory (along with Halloween 2018). Millennials will hype anything to the moon and back.
Alysia Mer David-Wasser
Alysia Mer David-Wasser 20 घंटे पहले
Editors are the worst: 6.5 minutes explaining "point 1. (which is point 3)". FECK THAT! Only thing wrong with this scene was Reid knowing who Freddie was. FF'S !!! EDIT, lol. i seem to be in the minority. Oh, well. When i think of editing, i think of continuity: i.e.: "Pretty Woman" has a LOT of bad edits.
nbfdmd
nbfdmd 5 घंटे पहले
If a scene leaves you feeling sick or nervous and that's not the intention, some extremely bad editing has taken place. This is becoming more and more common these days.
Rymo18
Rymo18 21 घंटे पहले
Wow boring
Jason Meadows
Jason Meadows 21 घंटे पहले
The problem with this movie is that they couldn't decide whether they wanted it to be a movie about Queen or Freddie Mercury. In my opinion, they just should have focused on the history of Queen, as a band. And I think Freddie would have wanted it that way. Freddie always tried to separate his personal life from his life in Queen and as an entertainer. He never considered himself to be greater than the band. When the movie focused on Freddie's love life, that's when the movie got really bogged down. The scenes with Queen in the studio and in concert, that's when the movie was really great.
Bhanu Prakash K R
Bhanu Prakash K R 21 घंटे पहले
Add your perspective in the title ... just because u feel it is not good doesn’t mean it’s completely wrong ...
qwargy
qwargy 21 घंटे पहले
Not to mention the terrible acting, wardrobe and script.
Lily Newman
Lily Newman 22 घंटे पहले
I watched this just to be really angry haha
Gabriel Borjas Garcia
Gabriel Borjas Garcia 22 घंटे पहले
Seems like this was your Master Class, Thomas
Evan Miller
Evan Miller 23 घंटे पहले
How much time do you have on your hands? It won an Oscar.
Pablo Pollaci
Pablo Pollaci 23 घंटे पहले
Stop respecting the cheap cinema rules established a century ago and do whatever you want dude... history rewards the daring
Danfuerth Gillis
Danfuerth Gillis 23 घंटे पहले
Lmfao I noticed that even on the trailer without even seeing the movie.
#MADCITYSTREETS
#MADCITYSTREETS 23 घंटे पहले
No. You're an idiot, and you simply fail to see how the editing reflects the tunnel vision tension of THAT moment for the band, but, particularly, Freddie Mercury.
Shot in the Heart
Shot in the Heart 23 घंटे पहले
Out of ALL the awards they could've won, this was the only one I was pretty sure they would lose
Miguel Zayne
Miguel Zayne 23 घंटे पहले
To be honest, I'm so accustomed to bad editing and generally needless cutting in movies and tv today I didn't even notice how bad it was in Bohemian Rhapsody. I was just glad John Ottman got an oscar for his work on the film since he will likely never get one for his music. To me that's what he got this oscar for. Not his editing on Bohemian Rhapsody but his previous work in film scoring.
James G
James G 23 घंटे पहले
Gotta love how butthurt some people are acting towards someone pointing out _objectively bad_ film-making. If you were able to enjoy the movie despite the garbage editing then good for you. But this stuff is editing 101, it isn't subjective. This is the kinda thing that movie goers subconsciously pick up on. Just the amount of people I've heard say that they felt there was something off or jarring about this movie is unreal. The very choppy, poor editing is noticeable, even if not on a conscious level. It drags down the movie experience for most people.
Patrick Völcker
Patrick Völcker दिन पहले
Cutting from the 🐓 to "Galileeeoooo" was so remarkable, everybody in the audience was laughing out loud, everybody kept that scene in mind... So at least a simple cut made people laugh. For me, that's worth an Oscar ;-)
joep de koning
joep de koning दिन पहले
@Thomas Flight I wonder what you have to say about this :) At 6:10. You see Brian looking at Rodger and John. Brian is going to sit straight but has a funny facial expression. -This could be either because he is jealous. -Or because he tries to be an example for the two little bit bold guys, that like to be kind of wild and get them to sit straight. (*sidenote) If you would fit Brian after them you would let him copy what Rodger and John does and is so called "unnecessary". +What could the background information about the members of queen at that point of their lives be? They could have made decisions because for instance Rodger and John felt like they were wannabe rockstars. Brian knew what he wanted and you could not tell Mr. Mercury that he wouldn't make it. And I would like to add that you shouldn't judge one part of creating a film (and i feel like post-production gets the most shit, they are the last involved) It might be a terrible edit to you, as stated by someone else: He could have turned a mess into something worth watching. Which could be a HELL!(yes caps) of a job.
Diega Siragusa
Diega Siragusa दिन पहले
i bought the movie on dvd because i like queen and the actors in it - and because it was so hyped up. then it took me five hours to get through the movie. i was really disappointed
dqw87
dqw87 दिन पहले
So you would have done it different, great. Doesn't mean your way is correct either. I liked the way it was shot. I liked knowing how the band was all reacting to things, not just Freddie. To each his own.
oresteez
oresteez दिन पहले
A minute and a half into your video and I can’t disagree enough. Maybe you and the people who agree with you have editing degrees which make you think you are somehow enlightened. I’m glad I can just sit back and enjoy a movie without nitpicking camera angles. And you really compared the scene when they meet the manager to one of the most intense scenes in The Godfather, right before Michael kills two people? Of course the GF filming was more “intense”. What’s your next comparison? How Freddie proposing isn’t as intense as Brad Pitt opening the box at the end of Seven?
Chris Layfield
Chris Layfield दिन पहले
I think they confused Best Editing with “How long is the all inclusive vacation you’re gonna gift me?”
Movie Remixer
Movie Remixer दिन पहले
great material, congrats! what an undeserved Oscar
Hufflepuff Student
Hufflepuff Student दिन पहले
Well, they won an Oscar for a reason. Have you?
Hufflepuff Student
Hufflepuff Student दिन पहले
J Squad Vlogs That’s in your opinion. I personally disagree. Compared to some other movies at the Oscars, this was one of the better ones.
J Squad Vlogs
J Squad Vlogs दिन पहले
Hufflepuff Student that argument doesn’t work it takes a completely different skill set to make a movie then it does to critique I’m not saying it’s bad but it’s not the best by Far
Hufflepuff Student
Hufflepuff Student दिन पहले
J Squad Vlogs Really, I’d like to see you make a movie.
J Squad Vlogs
J Squad Vlogs दिन पहले
Hufflepuff Student the MLB requires actual skill to be “good” you can’t honestly tell me this is the best edited movie of the year
Hufflepuff Student
Hufflepuff Student दिन पहले
J Squad Vlogs I’m guessing you have seen movies before, so you should know that the oscars is an event where people appreciate great movies. That’s like saying that the MLB is a joke
rodley25
rodley25 दिन पहले
ooh someone took an evening class.
ThaOg Bean
ThaOg Bean दिन पहले
I was In the theater tripping on Gummibears and I just thought i was really high, but this movie’s editing was absolut trash it just made me uncomfortable!!
[HD 4k] Oh Yeah Yeah
[HD 4k] Oh Yeah Yeah दिन पहले
My god this editing is such a clusterfuck
The Dudest
The Dudest दिन पहले
*Film review channel mentions "The God-Father"* *Turns video off*
Miranda Scott
Miranda Scott दिन पहले
I didn’t even think of that makes sense tho
Jonathan Giesbrecht
Jonathan Giesbrecht दिन पहले
Walter Murch didn't edit "The Godfather", William Reynolds and Peter Zinner did, according to IMDB.
Willy Queen
Willy Queen दिन पहले
However, It won! Eat it!
Mitch The Good Witch
Mitch The Good Witch दिन पहले
I literally didn’t notice any of this and really enjoyed this film .... 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️
pricila
pricila दिन पहले
im dizzy now lmao
Empiric Wisdom
Empiric Wisdom दिन पहले
Why are you conceding too much importance to the Academy Awards? Like if they weren't already corrupted and biased.
raffpants618
raffpants618 दिन पहले
the movie was awful - the lead actor good, but the story was so boring, the concert was so dumb. They tried to recreate the entire concert when the real version is better. And the editing was terrible. This is basically gay hollywood and queen jerking eachother off
Ramiro Garcia
Ramiro Garcia दिन पहले
The people who vote at the Oscars have no clue about films whatsoever, they just vote whatever popular film they saw and like the most, its ridiculous. Almost all the nominations and winners this year were underserved, special all of Black Panthers nominations and awards, a movie like Black Panther shouldnt win a single thing.
SkoczMiNaPukiel
SkoczMiNaPukiel दिन पहले
that dude deserves an Oscar for being Brian May's clone
BermudaTriangle Area51
BermudaTriangle Area51 दिन पहले
But I think that Bohemian Rhapsody compared to some other movies, is pretty good, even tho there are few imperfections
kittle kottle
kittle kottle दिन पहले
I'm only 5 minutes into the video and I already have motion sickness
kragen
kragen दिन पहले
great video
MCShvabo
MCShvabo दिन पहले
I didn't watch this move and HOLY SHIT LITTLE FINGER IS IN IT!
Amara
Amara दिन पहले
Rules are meant to be broken lol but I see what you mean
E5va
E5va दिन पहले
ah... so THIS is the reason why I didnt enjoy the movie. Thanks for the video!
Drunkenbum
Drunkenbum दिन पहले
the virgin video essay
뱈경린
뱈경린 दिन पहले
I have been a Queen fan for almost my entire life and it sucks because I was looking forward to this film for SO long...and it looked awful. I refused to give them my money... RIP Freddie, you deserve so much better.
अगला
Scenes from a Hat (Season 4.1)
1:00:38
दृश्य 93 000
10 Ways To Stop a Package Pirate..
5:54
दृश्य 796 184
Is This the STRONGEST GLUE Available?
11:30
Hollywood Celebrities Shutting Down Reporters
08:07
Top 10 Screw-up Moments in Oscars History
07:06
Freddie Mercury's 6 lovers/loves ♥
08:34
दृश्य 1 700 000
Language and Translation in Isle of Dogs
10:52
Unsolved Season 4 True Crime Marathon
3:10:22
The Impossible Hulk - SNL
3:26
दृश्य 2 562 090