अंधेरा

The Big Picture - Reservation : Who will benefit

Rajya Sabha TV
सदस्यता लें
दृश्य 98 969
97% 2 308 65

On the last day of the winter session of the Lok Sabha, the BJP-led government on Tuesday tabled a constitutional amendment bill to provide 10 per cent reservation in jobs and higher education to economically backward sections among the upper castes. The Union Cabinet, headed by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, had approved the Constitution (One Hundred and Twenty Fourth Amendment) Bill on Monday. Now that it has been passed in the Lower House, the Bill will be moved in the Rajya Sabha on Wednesday - the winter session has been extended by a day for members in the Upper House. The Bill needs to be passed by a special majority of two-thirds of members present in each House, not less than half the strength in both. Following this, it will have to be ratified by at least half of the state legislatures. It will also have to face legal challenges if any. On this edition of the big picture we analyse the Constitution 124th Amendment Bill.
Anchor- Frank Rausan Pereira
Guest-
Ashok Tandon, Senior Journalist
J. Sai Deepak, Advocate, Supreme Court
P. K. Malhotra, Former Secretary, Ministry of Law, GoI

 

8/01/2019

Union CabinetCabinetReservationReservation in Jobseconomically backward sectiongeneral categorySCSTOBCsconstitutional amendment billparliamentreservation billbackward poor peoplePM Narendra ModiLok SabhaRajya SabhaConstitutionQuota in jobeducationJobsModi Government10% quotaSupreme CourtModi govt approvesWinter SessionRSTVRajya Sabha TV

शेयर करें:

शेयर करें:

वीडियो डाउनलोड करें:

लिंक लोड हो रहा है.....

में जोड़े:

मेरी संगीतसूची
बाद में देखना
टिप्पणियाँ 379
Varsha Rajput
Varsha Rajput 9 दिन पहले
J. Sai Deepak. I get happy and hopeful whenever I see him in the panel. When he spoke he laid down the whole case clearly on table for everyone to see. Such articulation, clarity and reason.
Donald Trump
Donald Trump महीने पहले
ST reservation benefits only the Meenas tribe
Arnab Sen
Arnab Sen 2 महीने पहले
In India we need deserve people rather than on reserved people
Pawan Sharma
Pawan Sharma 2 महीने पहले
There should be no reservation on caste basis ,it should be for every people who belongs to economically weaker sectionson or Otherwise reservation should be abolished completely because critical thinking can not be developed in people's mind by providing the so-called reservation,it should be on the basis of nondiscrimination,each& every politicians are making mockery of the poor, Provide only initial support to every people in every field...if they have sense of conscienceness & their potentials ,they can easily uplift themselves otherwise self God also can't change their so-called situations...
Allen Sebastian
Allen Sebastian 2 महीने पहले
I think there should have been a panelist who strongly opposed this legislation to grab both the sides of the argument
Lakshay Vashistha
Lakshay Vashistha 2 महीने पहले
Such a great panel comprising of all the intellects. It feels so good to watch such debates.
Raj Kumar
Raj Kumar 3 महीने पहले
SIR Sai Deepak YOUR INFORMATION VERY HELP US AND WE WILL SEE YOUR BECOME CJI OF INDIA
Harsha Hb
Harsha Hb 4 महीने पहले
Deepak always rocks
om pranav
om pranav 4 महीने पहले
Mr. malhotra has been crying for reservation based on caste basis for a period exceeding 10 years. At the same time he must realise that malhotra becoming a malhotra has enjoyed the reservation benefits for more than 2000 years. This sophistication has come at the cost of brutal repressions since ages. Please realise this aspect.
Kavitha Gowrav
Kavitha Gowrav 4 महीने पहले
those indulge in castism have politicians backing like CT Ravi bjp politician
Kavitha Gowrav
Kavitha Gowrav 4 महीने पहले
those indulge in castism have politicians backing like CT Ravi bjp politician
Kavitha Gowrav
Kavitha Gowrav 4 महीने पहले
all other castes will join hands to harrass scheduled castes n scheduled tribes in work places
Kavitha Gowrav
Kavitha Gowrav 4 महीने पहले
you stop castism n bring in equality still there is lot of inequality n castism n harrassment on basis of caste then u stop reservation..survey it still well educated have such kind of mindset of descriminating on scheduled castes, scheduled castes are not getting rental houses just because they belong to scheduled castes...now a days descrimination on sc increased in well educated(literate not really well educated) upper castes..
Kavitha Gowrav
Kavitha Gowrav 4 महीने पहले
they will create job vacancies by kicking out scheduled castes this what they are doing now, torturing scheduled castes
Rohit patel
Rohit patel 4 महीने पहले
It's the best moments to work on only soul basis of all the reservations as economical challenging conditions
TamilArjun
TamilArjun 4 महीने पहले
To divide & rule and mess up society. British created caste to divide people into chunks + mixed with Manu Dharma + created reservation policy to legalize British created caste divisions. One could notice, one side preserve caste reservations and another side tell people that going to annihilate caste system. Who owns 300 acres of farmland and literally rules... kept in backward caste... Shocking... Enjoy Play double game
mataiba rangna
mataiba rangna 4 महीने पहले
create jobs instead of making reservation. Govt.need to invest in Manufacturing sectors, China stands today because of this. reservation reservation reservation....😐😐😐
bharath
bharath 4 महीने पहले
How can Sai Deepak remember such minute intricacies in the laws, what a memory..
sankey singh
sankey singh 4 महीने पहले
If all obc,st/sc all are the poor why they not waant reservation on economic basic not basic on cast
saivikranth deshpande
saivikranth deshpande 4 महीने पहले
J.Sai Deepak sir has immense knowlege
dhiraj bankar
dhiraj bankar 4 महीने पहले
Where are we heading towards as a nation?? Our whole discourse must be to bring equality in our society with regard to status and opportunity.We should be moving towards the path of equal society where everyone will be able to compete on his/her merit.To this extent debate should be "how to achieve equality,how to uplift weaker ones,deprieved of opportunities,etc" and finally "how to scrap all kind of reservation". Economic criteria in a developing country like India where per capita income is too less in comparison to europe or other developed nations,is not a feasible way to empower the marginalised. There is difference between "poverty" of person who is born in higher caste and who is born in lower caste.In india 'caste dynamics'are more challenging than 'class dynamics'.If this goes on- at every point of time there will be certain sections who are economically weaker-then day is not so far when there will be 100 % reservation.Even at that time also someone will be marginalised economically. Our economic policy,educational policy and political culture needs to change substantially to bring about equality,equity and justice to all. Tnx rs tv
Arun Sivaraman
Arun Sivaraman 4 महीने पहले
No need of states ratification since there is no amendments on the federal provisions,only special majority is needed to amend the fundamental rights
Yogita Kukreja
Yogita Kukreja 4 महीने पहले
how is 8 lakh the bar for poverty in India ? If it includes 95% of people then what's the point of reservation? can we keep 2 lakh per annum and 7.99 lakh per annum under same category?? Making reservation more than 50%, is it just??
sankey singh
sankey singh 4 महीने पहले
Obc creamy layer baar also 8lac
A. M.
A. M. 4 महीने पहले
BJP is real bane for this country in every sense.
A. M.
A. M. 4 महीने पहले
Education and health is needed for all not lollipop of reservation. These two most important things are totally ignored in public debate.
A google user
A google user 4 महीने पहले
he said that the price of a plot is higher in the urban area than rural area but the cost of living is also higher in the urban area
ADNAN RASHEED
ADNAN RASHEED 4 महीने पहले
Economic reservation who will benefit? 124th Constitutional amendment bill 10% reservation to economically backward Need a half the strength of house Demand of people long time Caste basis someupliftment is done No provision in Constitution- now fone- previously not done No ratification of state required 70% popu- sc St obc 30% no reservations No jobs are we going to make jobs 8l rupees,1000sqft,5 acre bottom line - population quiet large Urban area less than square feet but value is 30 crore Probably 90% population come under this category- 10% enough or not? Impementation not clear 50% reservation many states met Made in indira sawney case That time no article 15-6 and 16-6 (9th schedule - immune from challenge if not question basic structure of Constitution) Political will- polarisation Political consensus seen in this Tamil Nadu 69% reservation- not revoked Cap on caste based reservation- this is not caste based Constitution is a living document- can interpretat from time to time Dpsp early not implement now start doing Basic structure is a sci introduction- so they may come with a new one in future- violate a basic structure is not question big 2014- charter case- reservation- sci said- new parameters should be discussed to identify the backwardness of distruss community No mention of economic reservation in indira sahwney judgement Jobs are connected with this - youth are concerned about this Initially reservation was for 10 years- till a time come to take away -still not tookoff Least devisive metric is economic metric It Should have been start from creamy layer Elections caste arithmetic - economic reservation don't account political benefit
Maheshkumar Mulge Mulge
Maheshkumar Mulge Mulge 4 महीने पहले
Thanks all panelists and staffs of rstv
Yogish K
Yogish K 4 महीने पहले
Remove caste reservation ......It won't make India grow...Unskilled people will be chosen as per caste reservation...Prefer merit and talent first...Give 20 % reservation to who is talented,skillfull and economically poor so Efficiency will be created in govt jobs and talented,poor people get chance to grow
Jihadi Socio Gaming
Jihadi Socio Gaming 4 महीने पहले
Frank looks dope .. keep the beard bro
adi ct
adi ct 4 महीने पहले
this reservation is sure to attract general category.. have bad conditions like 8 lakh limit but principle is good economic weakness.. modern world everything depwnds on money. so ppl who doesnt have money need something for there development
Gautam Sachdev
Gautam Sachdev 5 महीने पहले
👌👌
zafar. ul haq
zafar. ul haq 5 महीने पहले
Sai deepak - right wing lawyer, Ashok Tandon - media advisor to Vajpayee. LOL The Rajya Sabha's debates are getting hijacked.
ajay singh
ajay singh 5 महीने पहले
After giving reservation in education, I don't think there is any need to give reservation in jobs to the economically weaker section
Papa 99
Papa 99 5 महीने पहले
Discrimination must go Reservation must stay
abinash bhil
abinash bhil 5 महीने पहले
very ordinary debate...no dissent..they too afraid of criticism as all the political parties do.....its fine if u want to uplit poor people among the upper caste but elligibility criteria is shocking to me...8 lakh,5 acre,1000 square feet,,hahaha.....it surely need to be reassesed..
राहुल पांडेय्
राहुल पांडेय् 5 महीने पहले
It was same with obc layer.. That's why
deepika tiwari
deepika tiwari 5 महीने पहले
Remove caste remove reservation
Rathi Singh
Rathi Singh 5 महीने पहले
So question of merit, effieciency in service etc is no more. who earn 8 lakh is Poor.Hypocrite!!!
Mohit Yadav
Mohit Yadav 5 महीने पहले
Somebody please correct me: 10% reservation for 95% people belonging to General category. Aren't they getting selected already within the 50% open category? Is it that 5% from general category are getting selected for say 20-30%? No. So basically it reserves people who are getting selected in any case. Its like reserving 99% seats for Indians. It makes no difference!! Its a mere Jumla.
abhijit mondal
abhijit mondal 3 महीने पहले
what you are saying is correct.It is completely redundant
राहुल पांडेय्
राहुल पांडेय् 5 महीने पहले
10% reservation is for general category.. Means total - SC/ST- OBC.. So it is around 30% of population.. 30% is reserved for 10% of seats.. And rest 40% are unreserved seats means whole 100% can compete for that
Charles Gangmeih
Charles Gangmeih 5 महीने पहले
I see 8 lakhs income cap as utterly nonsense & inflated. My family earns 3-4.5 lakhs annual income, & we were considered middle income family in my village. My fellow villagers earns less than 70,000 thousands a year. From our tribal families point of view, 8 lakhs income is a luxury.
Vikash Sharma
Vikash Sharma 4 महीने पहले
on the par with the creamy layer in OBC
aditya gupta
aditya gupta 5 महीने पहले
Avoid tondon sir in panel from next time. Everything else is fine.
kumar manglam
kumar manglam 5 महीने पहले
Sai sir is really lawyer to comprehend
kumar manglam
kumar manglam 5 महीने पहले
Only tondon sir is making balance between religion and politics
Sai kummar
Sai kummar 5 महीने पहले
jail SAI deepak is my favorite speaker
Avinaash Sharma
Avinaash Sharma 5 महीने पहले
Very informative and useful debate. Thanks Rajan and Deepak
Priyanka Dubey
Priyanka Dubey 5 महीने पहले
J Sai Deepak you are my favourite ❤️
Haritha V
Haritha V 5 महीने पहले
Above all transparency in recruitments should be brought in Govt. Institutions. Back door entry and nepotism should be pulled out.This itself can bring vacancies to genuine candidates.Timely result announcement without laging for several years is a must.Instead speaking about jobless youth and framing policies for job creation, this is what is the need of hour.
Chhaya Chaudhary
Chhaya Chaudhary 5 महीने पहले
The day reservation ends, it will be like the aftermath of LPG reforms, where the efficient rose to prominence & spurred India on the path of unprecedented economic growth while the incompetent perished... Similarly, the administration will attract the best talent & become efficient, while the non competent will be forced to pursue excellence & get admissions on the basis of merit!
rishabh soni
rishabh soni 5 महीने पहले
J. sai deepak you are awesome 👏✊👍
Ram S
Ram S 5 महीने पहले
I can see lot of comment here saying it is a good. Move. These people are like suprresed for thousand of year.. just a mere 100 year is enough for them to regain? I personally seen many village Don't even has toilet in SC colony! I am studying in a suburban college. In our college there only 0.75% people are SC ST. according to report about 67% of SC and 91% of ST socially depressed (less than 1 lakh income). Inum avanga valarave ila.. that's true.. if you really have talent you sure can be candidate of General. I compete my college in general category even I'm an OBC. see the data. We need to prove that everyone equal in the country. No higher official in Tamil Nadu government nor Indian government has SC/ST person. This is not incidental.
Ram S
Ram S 4 महीने पहले
@Dust Particle I already mentioned my data. You can't just make a blind judgement. Still 80% ST people don't have higher education in survey did on Orissa and Bihar. They deserve a lot than the sick bhramins
Dust Particle
Dust Particle 4 महीने पहले
Nowadays SC and ST people are very rich. They dont deserve reservation anymore.
Keerthana Sivasubramanian
Keerthana Sivasubramanian 5 महीने पहले
I can see only one comment like this.... Entire nation is favour of economic reservation... Reservation is for social upliftment, not for economic upliftment. If they want economic upliftment they can promote good economic schemes... But this reservation is for power related issues like higher jobs and education purely not for economic.... காலங்காலமா சாதிய சொல்லிதான் இங்கு கல்வி மறுக்கப்பட்து. அப்போ அதே சாதியை வைத்து தான் ஒதிக்கீடு வாங்கவேண்டும். இவங்களோட பொருளாதாரம் அரசு வேலைல தான் தீர்க்கமுடியுமா!! ஏன் தொழில்ல பொருளாதாரம் பெற முடியாத.... Still now reservation is loss for country's development nu sonnangala... Ippo mattum country valarum??? What is that 10%??? From which committee they are deriving 10%.... Pure election stunts....
Sarin Sajeev
Sarin Sajeev 5 महीने पहले
Sir that beard doesn’t suit u.... Ur clean shaven look was better I think....
Vivek Ravi
Vivek Ravi 5 महीने पहले
Who else is here only for Sai Deepak?
Chaitanya Rathod
Chaitanya Rathod 5 महीने पहले
THANK YOU
anurag singh
anurag singh 5 महीने पहले
And respected Sir and former Bureaucrat doesn't know about reservation and confusing political reservation with reservation for public.. plz correct me if m wrong.
Mansi Pal
Mansi Pal 5 महीने पहले
Economic basis dn should also be applied for SCs and STs... Aur 70 saal... And I think Mr. Tandon is living in his own utopia.. this is also a political move and we can see it clearly...
Internet - Where every dolt is an expert
Internet - Where every dolt is an expert 5 महीने पहले
sc st obc population is not 70 percent. It is a big myth based on false census done in 1930. The new data based on national survey says that obc r only around 30 to 35. Most of them r classified arbitrarily based on vote banks without any regard to real backwardness criteria. Economic criteria and location of ppl where they live r only criteria which decides their access to upward mobility.
Mini Shukla
Mini Shukla 5 महीने पहले
Disappointed with RStv for a biased debate.
Sidhant Negi
Sidhant Negi 5 महीने पहले
I would say it's a welcoming idea of giving reservation solely on the basis of economic parameters, not only to upper cast but to everyone irrespective of caste.....it's already been 70 years NOW!!
Tilak Nayak
Tilak Nayak 5 महीने पहले
Wonderful debate Frank... Keep going... Luv RSTV♥️
Varun Rathi
Varun Rathi 5 महीने पहले
Hi, Guys I have a doubt at time 6:09-6:10 J Sai Deepak talked about article 15(6) and article 16(6) but i have been looking for these in PM bakshi the constituion of india I can't find article 15(6) or 16(6).............Can please someone tell me what are these.....????
saluka1000
saluka1000 5 महीने पहले
what I got from it, a- person whose salary is 65k per month is poor, though most of the gov jobs dont provide this package at initial level at least, b- political parties could not oppose because they cant afford it, may be they like it or not. c- Its leading to a more refined aspect of reservation like for women, 3genders, refugees etc, now what lead the gov to take this step in the last day of parliament or BJP gov, d - no data is given to back the this argument of backwardness and creamy layer, as per my knowledge. 1-It failed to create the jobs in gov and pvt field both miserably as it had promised and made people dream by make in india and other programs. 2- Education system is junk, it can produce cheap labor for USA not scientists or ENTREPRENEURS. 3- Neta have enough money to send their children abroad for study and most of the indian collages belong to them. 4 - If we really want progress, will have to appreciate merit not cast. its better to make the cast meritorious not the merit on cast. pls forgive for mistakes :)
dazzlingstar1000
dazzlingstar1000 5 महीने पहले
Though good,it was one sided.There wasn't any argument against reducing pie of General Merit candidates.
shivaram motukuri
shivaram motukuri 5 महीने पहले
Even with 20% reservation what good is it with no jobs?? despite the promises there is huge drop in unemployment, ab ki baar bye bye modi sarkar
राहुल पांडेय्
राहुल पांडेय् 5 महीने पहले
There is less jobs in government sector because of artificial intelligence and privatization.. But there is increase in private jobs..I know you will say that is not because of government but that is because of policies of government
MALIK MOHIT
MALIK MOHIT 5 महीने पहले
All panelist seem like puppet of govt in every discussion ....... except CK vasni sir
prem chand
prem chand 5 महीने पहले
TILL DATE RESERVATION IS SCOLDED HEAVILY .....I AM VICTIM OF THAT BUT HOW SUDDEN IT BECAME GOOD
MALIK MOHIT
MALIK MOHIT 5 महीने पहले
Totally biased discussion.......... No criticism of govt ever on this channel.......
Grand Master
Grand Master 5 महीने पहले
It will initiate mass brain drain. China and USA will have the best brains working for country. Merit in dustbin. Keep finding substandard doctors and teachers that will drown the nation. India will not die but it will exist as a blot on face of world. A country with such intellectual and hard working population will never develop and the best among all will work for the West.
MACHO VISUALS
MACHO VISUALS 5 महीने पहले
The property cost can be high, that cannot fetch monthly income or raise standard of living or provide jobs or education merit seats. A home below 1000sqft in bangalore is not going to fetch a large amount
MANOJ
MANOJ 5 महीने पहले
Reservation is only for uplifting the weaker sections.... I agree the reservation but where are the fucking jobssssss. Gov should order the all selection commission to fill the vacant seats in central as well as state.....
sanjay reddy
sanjay reddy 5 महीने पहले
How brilliant sai deepak is seriously he has referred to the judgement given by ranjan gogoi n nariman to an extent that he also mentioned the para number n what exactly they said ...This has flattered me what a way to talk about an issue he's a true genius n inspiring
Sarthak Banduni
Sarthak Banduni 5 महीने पहले
We want reservation for obc and economically weakers sections in parliament also! Women reservation bill(2008) has been passed by rajya sabha in 2008.Why is lok sabha not passing it? Jab apni seat pr khatra Hoga toh samaj ayega politicians ko
Paridhi Giriya
Paridhi Giriya 5 महीने पहले
Panelists kept on repeating how this bill has got unanimous support across political and national spectrum yet not a single comment lauding this move of govt! Strange!
Vikrant Parmar
Vikrant Parmar 5 महीने पहले
sai deepak....spoke elegantly
let's live , let's wakeup
let's live , let's wakeup 5 महीने पहले
👌nice debate
Jevesh Chauhan
Jevesh Chauhan 5 महीने पहले
Economic criteria should be 5lk if u really want weaker section to get benefit
Jevesh Chauhan
Jevesh Chauhan 5 महीने पहले
संविधान निर्माताओ ने माना था सामाजिक अन्याय हुआ था इसलिए सबने 10 सालो के लिए आरक्षण का खुले दिल से स्वागत किया था।आज 56 इंच की छाती ठोक के मन की बात बोल क्यों नहीं देते हमने स्वतंत्रता के बाद सामाजिक अन्याय को खत्म नही कर पाने के साथ साथ समाज में आर्थिक अन्याय को भी जन्म दिया जिसने स्वर्णो को भी पिछड़ा कर दिया । मन की बात कह क्यों नही देते सारे प्रयास असफल हो गए इसलिए हम राजनेताओ ने दलाली चालू कर दी है 10% कि वो भी अपने मालिक(जनता) के साथ। सारे राजनेता आज सदन मैं एक स्वर के साथ गूंगे हो गए हैं और देश की विफलता को छुपाने के लिए आरक्षण को क्रांतिकारी कदम बता रहें हैं। आज एक बात तो अच्छी हुई की हमने माना दलित और स्वर्ण कही तो साथ खड़े हैं चाहे वो आर्थिक पिछड़े पन में ही सही। आज मेरा देश पिछड़ गया हैं ...
Rahul Ranjan
Rahul Ranjan 5 महीने पहले
There is no dissenting voice here... The whole panels are so called upper castes ... All are biased... Now meritorious are not meritorious enough...
Ramesh Kumaran
Ramesh Kumaran 5 महीने पहले
Bjp ko abort karo 2019 may. Ye 10% waalo ka baapich nai hai.Lawaaris 10 percent.
Manisha Kumari
Manisha Kumari 5 महीने पहले
J.Sai Deepak makes discussion colourful in all aspects of the topic.Very nice 😃
Ramesh Kumaran
Ramesh Kumaran 5 महीने पहले
General category seats are already reserved for FC, now you give them another 10,which makes it 60.5% reservation for FC. Further more OBCs are a minority in many states and FC a majority. So OBC presence won't be there and all these seats will be won by FC. So FC on the national level are getting a lion's share of the seats. Only 6 to 12% of the 27 % of the quota seats or jobs are being filled by the OBC. Why so? The remainder must be gulped by the FC using fake certificates or the OBC guys are selling their caste certificates because they may not be yet good enough to work in a govt job.That shows the social backwardness.
prateek
prateek 5 महीने पहले
At the end it is the middle class that has to suffer. The middle class are responsible for paying all the taxes, working their ass off for the progress of this country and at the end they are most persecuted. Boycott income tax!
Piyush Gour
Piyush Gour 5 महीने पहले
First of all it will not gonna benefit the economically weaker section because the cap is 8 lakh. Now a person who earns 66000 per month is equivalent to person who earns 10000 per month. And the fruits of this 10% reservation will be taken by a person earning 66000 per month because he has much better facilities and can prepare well for govt jobs. *This is just a vote bank Act to cover 96% peoples and not at all for economically Weaker section otherwise the cap would be 3 lakh approx*
Sujit Kumar
Sujit Kumar 5 महीने पहले
where does reservation solves the issue of financial backwardness. Imagine a situation where a student who is financially backward and he clears an examination and goes in a wonderful univrsity, now how does he pays the fees at a time where government is busy privatising things and giving huge autonomy to government universities.
roaring banjara ##
roaring banjara ## 5 महीने पहले
But annually 8lakhs income? ,how can a family with 8lakhs per annum income be poor? I can't understand why they are considered poor
Only IAS
Only IAS 5 महीने पहले
95% of Indians Income is below 8 lacs(according to ITR they file)...all are eligible almost... Only 76 lakh Indians showed income of over Rs 5 lakh: Jaitley www.thehindubusinessline.com/economy/budget/only-76-lakh-indians-showed-income-of-over-rs-5-lakh-jaitley/article9514752.ece PS: Reservation is failure...Representation of SC,ST, OBC is dismal according to their respective population..Almost 85% population still legging behind and still curse by General category for backwardness of india...where they should go? why such aghast inequality of representation and backwardness if schemes and programme are 200% successful with 1000 efficiency and 10000% accuracy by Meritorious General category top bureaucrats with 0 % corruption rates. Brain drain in not because of people find hard to find jobs here ...everyone is looking for better opportunity and good pay..it is usually high is developed countries...and if this brain drain logic applies strictly then Indian NRI who send highest remittances home are nothing but those who cant find jobs, hated their country and went away...Indian future generation need to be sensitive to the problems...both sides are going crazy this needs some mediation and dialouge...which is not seems to happen now a days...
Prateek Gupta
Prateek Gupta 5 महीने पहले
If we are providing reservations to the economically backward society then that means that the govt schemes and programmes in the pas for the development of poor has not been properly implemented and isnt it had the govt should focus on them by properly implementing the schemes making them self reliant that they come up the level of economic poverty by hardwork and the criteria given by the govt which may include a very large no of population that means a very few high income society will be left with 40% of the seats.
prafull kumar
prafull kumar 5 महीने पहले
This is caste based , it is for general caste
girly girly girl zehra
girly girly girl zehra 5 महीने पहले
Ek aur lolipop Wu hamari hi pocket se nikal k hume dere😅
sushain upadhyay
sushain upadhyay 5 महीने पहले
Any intellectual here tell me... Someone earning 70,000 and have 3 kids, while other earning 65,000 per month and have 1 kid. Who is more economically backward ?? This bill is a myth. It is a ploy to divide generals. Please people don't support this. Earlier you people used to make so wonderful points against this crap reservation, what has happened to you people?? Lollipop mil gya KHUSH HO GYE....i swear I'll challenge this bill, not now.. but definitely in the future... I won't let this bill be there permanently. This impotent politicians will never dare to abolish it, judiciary is the ONLY HOPE.
clarkent
clarkent 5 महीने पहले
Now come to reservation on religious lines
clarkent
clarkent 5 महीने पहले
Great video.
Naveen Kumar
Naveen Kumar 5 महीने पहले
It's disgusting. Those who were for meritocracy are asking for reservations. And in our country 30% people live below poverty line and can barely earn 3000 INR per month but people with 65000 INR per month are considered poor. Pathetic!
Chanakya Mishra
Chanakya Mishra 5 महीने पहले
Lots of thanks...to Rajyasabha TV... Special thanks to Mr. Pereira
Hanumant Upadhyay
Hanumant Upadhyay 5 महीने पहले
Why aren't they demanding reservations in the Armed Forces? Why aren't they protesting for it?
Vishnu Bansal
Vishnu Bansal 5 महीने पहले
Ashok tandon is useless guy.... He is just like uncle giving lecture on morality. With information less
abhishek kumar
abhishek kumar 5 महीने पहले
Loved watching Deepak, but seems like Mr. Tandon and Mr. Malhotra(which he is) are BJP spokespersons.
P K
P K 5 महीने पहले
only important point is that in indira sahwney vs union of india 50 % cap imposed was only on caste based reservation, and not on other criteria. topic close
alok yadav
alok yadav 5 महीने पहले
U get stupid laws to pass and people will be there to support it ... i guess earlier reservation criteria needed to be changed or rationalized first ... i mean for god sake how can u take 8 lakh of income as benchmark ... entire country probably will come under it ... god where are we heading .... now ....if the governmnta really care abt the poor and needy ones they should bring the income criteria down upto i guess 4 lkh or somthing so tht only those who are really deserving should get the benefit and on the othr hand gov should focus on improving the quality of education and bringing out more jobs .... othrwise no use of reservation coz u help people get degress but with no jobs u get more educated “ berojgars “ in themarket ... and country will be heading towrds a crisis like scenario
Albin George
Albin George 5 महीने पहले
UPSC study material!
DEEPIK A
DEEPIK A 5 महीने पहले
Ab general wale kaise kahenege ki reservation hatao 😂😂😂😂😂 Ab general me bhi category Ho Jayega upper general middle general lower general 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
RAHUL SHARMA
RAHUL SHARMA 5 महीने पहले
Me to kah raha ho hatao hum besharam nahi hai na 2 ghante jyada paadh longa kisi ki talent ko sarminda nahi karonga
sushain upadhyay
sushain upadhyay 5 महीने पहले
Politicians are so cruel that they created divisions in general category, there will never be unity.
अगला
Helicopter Crash in New York City
1:01
दृश्य 1 747 305
The Collapse of the American Empire?
27:43
दृश्य 2 500 000
Sister Q&A - Khloé and Kylie
3:50
दृश्य 5 062 944
imbiamba jombes
4:21
दृश्य 607 492
SOMI (전소미) - 'BIRTHDAY' M/V
3:11
दृश्य 13 070 488
The Green New Deal, explained
7:30
दृश्य 706 834
Boston Dynamics: New Robots Now Fight Back
3:32