What 40,000 Videos Tell Us About The Trending Tab

Coffee Break
सदस्यता लें
दृश्य 1 115 914
98% 122 931 1 251

Is the trending tab rigged against creators? Is late night dominating the charts? Why does it feel your favorite controversial creator never trends. All of that and more, in the first ever data-driven look at the trending tab.
To see the nuts and bolts of this video, a more in-depth explanation of what I did, go here: in-vid.net/video/वीडियो-sEvtpj-uChA.html
Support is greatly appreciated:
Patreon: www.patreon.com/Coffee_Break
Twitter: twitter.com/coffeebreak_YT
Facebook: facebook.com/CoffeeBreak42/
Reddits: reddit.com/r/coffeebreak
Discord: discord.gg/EAbgdg7
Marc Rebillet [dude is a musical genius]
Mitchell Jolly's Website
Original Dataset collected by Mitchell
Classification was done by myself and over 70 others who contributed to crowdsourcing our data for the US Dataset.
To see more about how I made this video, a more in-depth explanation of what I did, go here:
Want to know about other work that's being done at looking at the output of these impossibly complicated algorithms?
Ever want a look at what trending would be like without the bias? Check out Rian Hunter's work on Fair Trending!!!!
A brilliant video from Derek of Veritasium about how to think about trending videos: My Video Went Viral. Here's Why | It was a huge Today I found out moment and he even helped me with this video's thumbnail!!! Go give him some love, not that he needs it after his Why Are 96,000,000 Black Balls on This Reservoir? video.
Featured in Pewdiepie ‘s video KSI is cancelled
See it here: in-vid.net/video/वीडियो-0SSrvjDaVFA.html&lc=UgxuiNyOaycvT6KXs0F4AaABAg



शेयर करें:

शेयर करें:

वीडियो डाउनलोड करें:

लिंक लोड हो रहा है.....

में जोड़े:

मेरी संगीतसूची
बाद में देखना
टिप्पणियाँ 10 368
Coffee Break
Coffee Break 6 महीने पहले
EDIT: who’s here from pew news?? Welcome 9yr olds to my channel! Like for Mary Ham, comment for poppy or Gloria. if you like this video, the two biggest things you can do to get it seen are a) watch the entirety of it. and b) share it with one person. I really would like other IN-vidrs to see this, but I need your help.
William Johnston
William Johnston महीने पहले
blip boop, umm... vox is 100% traditional media. Their base is not mainly youtube. IN-vid is a tiny part of what they do.
Megumi Randall
Megumi Randall 3 महीने पहले
Did you guys take video shares into account when deciding the reason why certain channels are trending?
Tams80 3 महीने पहले
@blip boop Vox have their own offices in New York, with hiring teams, production teams, the works. They are traditional media.
Sam K
Sam K 3 महीने पहले
Watched, liked, shared 👉 great video
Sage Martineau
Sage Martineau 2 दिन पहले
Vox was created in 2014, and they make actually good content that isnt covered by mainstream media
Sage Martineau
Sage Martineau 2 दिन पहले
Vox is awesome, I dont see why their youtube has to count as traditional media.
Phun Makara
Phun Makara 2 दिन पहले
The Social Blade
The Social Blade 3 दिन पहले
IN-vid is liberal and they are trying to keep liberal media alive. You won't see Fox trending. Just my opinion
Charles Rob
Charles Rob 3 दिन पहले
11:30 black box? hmmmm... did you study software engineering? just curious.
Charles Rob
Charles Rob 3 दिन पहले
You make more Ad revenue off views in America rather than outside of the US as well...
Brain Grip
Brain Grip 6 दिन पहले
The perfect way to succeed on IN-vid (PARODY & enable subtitles for english subs ): in-vid.net/video/%E0%A4%B5%E0%A5%80%E0%A4%A1%E0%A4%BF%E0%A4%AF%E0%A5%8B-npdwyKl7_yg.html
Pinterest Success Marketing
Pinterest Success Marketing 10 दिन पहले
This is Black Hat from Google ...
Michael David
Michael David 14 दिन पहले
pretty sure traditional media is paying youtube to prop them up or its a political bias. Did you do trending on conservatives vs liberal creators on trending?
Wes Lee
Wes Lee 15 दिन पहले
Seems suspicious when I make smart comments that go ignored, while some fool has 400 likes w no content. Hackers!
Sadhanabrata Roy
Sadhanabrata Roy 15 दिन पहले
My trending tab is the least used tab in youtube menu bar.It's full of pointless things none of which I am interested in. Great youtubers like EEEVLOG, BLACKPENREDPEN, JEREMY FIELDING, ELECTROBOOM never make it to trending (not even Boston Dynamics). Next topic : why is IN-vid so baised against educational and artistic creators while creating IN-vid REWIND?
Aishik Ashraf
Aishik Ashraf 17 दिन पहले
Who's here after PewDiePie's video?
cyanmanta 18 दिन पहले
I looked at the trending tab once. For about 30 seconds. Didn’t click on anything, just wondered why anyone would want to watch any of that shit.
MrViridian 19 दिन पहले
All this does is make me want to become a part of the creator community even more We will make this better.
Adam 20 दिन पहले
yeah I never watch trending
An Gry
An Gry 23 दिन पहले
That's gangster... Chinese CCP style gangster... damn...
CreatureOfGoddess 27 दिन पहले
The carnival game of Fame...
samkachar 28 दिन पहले
I wouldve liked to see other areas besides news. Reason being, i can somewhat see why old media is going to trend easier. They have professional journalists. Its important to have people breaking news stories to know how to vet a story properly and have gone through NYU jschool, and perhaps worked for a big network. Im not saying we should go ahead and discount everyones opinion that doesnt fit that criteria, but i think it should be weighted appropriately. Furthermore I'd be quicker to side with IN-vidrs on other content. But then again, if something is happening in the world maybe an astroid is headed for earth. Id want an astrophysicist talking about it over a guy who is just interested in talking about space. Like if u agree, throw me your hate and thumbs down u don't. Im interested either way.
Boris Nova
Boris Nova महीने पहले
It's trash aimed at kids. Google has fucked youtube since the day they bought it. Now it's just a giant corporate fuck fest with endless ads.
Supriya Ananda
Supriya Ananda महीने पहले
Welcome to HINDU Guru - ASK whatever you may need - You will be answered twitter.com/SriNithyananda Nithyananda @SriNithyananda Reviver of Kailaasa - the enlightened civilization, greatest and only Hindu nation Life bliss IN-vid channel in-vid.net/u-LifeBlissFoundation
Ian Love
Ian Love महीने पहले
"IN-vid fixing the system." It won't. Not gonna happen. I've been regularly on this site (as a viewer, not a content creator) since 2009/2010; this shit is constant. IN-vid does not intend to fix problems, it historically has only created more. The weeks or sometimes even months-late claims that they've "heard our concerns" and that they're "working to fix the problem" are a regular, consistent part of the company's engagement with the community, boiled down to an exact science. The trouble is that most of the time their promises are bullshit. Do not trust IN-vid. Trust yourselves, and keep doing videos and experiments like _these_. If IN-vid isn't going to be clear with us, and if they don't intend to fix things when the community needs them to be, then the best that can be done in the short term is keeping other creators informed on how this all works.
D’ OPULENT VLOG महीने पहले
Very interesting topic. Thanks for sharing. I hope I can get more followers like you. Thanks a lot .
S_L_H महीने पहले
I don't think I've ever used the trending tab but that's about accurate, build a base and then sell em out for agendas.
John Collett
John Collett महीने पहले
I LOVE RUKA RUKA ALI. !!! He's the SHIT! sorry if u don't trend now
Jaded1 महीने पहले
Big money brings corruption. IN-vid used to be an avenue for the independent creator, not anymore. New rules and regulations have ensured the small creator will never breakthrough with any success.
isuru udayanga
isuru udayanga महीने पहले
E. V.
E. V. महीने पहले
wow, google is evil not only in a global sense, but even in such petty cases.
timbargen महीने पहले
Opened trending tab after watching this video. IN-vid app immediately crashed. _Coincidence?_
[BLD]PAI-II: Jay महीने पहले
PewDiePie isn't actually trending in Germany... I just watch him a few million times.
attlee2010 महीने पहले
Some great analysis
Glass Marble
Glass Marble महीने पहले
NOW trans, gays and fallen "angels"
Terrakinetic महीने पहले
Why is he so frenetic? It makes him seem so untrustworthy.
Real.Piece.Of.Work महीने पहले
I never even look at 'trending' because i know it's total dog shit.
Victor Cates
Victor Cates महीने पहले
There are social costs to everyone playing by the same rules if someone controversial makes Trending (even if the video in question is benign). But there's an issue if traditional media is playing for relevance, placement on youtube AND generates self serving criticism of youtube.
_Paws_ महीने पहले
IN-vid invented a new form censorship in the guise of bots and the algorithm.
Andrew Miller
Andrew Miller महीने पहले
Step one: go on trending tab Step two: find traditional media Step three: dislike video Step four:leave a comment that round about says gtfo our platform
ElementalMaker महीने पहले
Wow I knew Suso was a good liar, but damn the trending situation is even worse than I thought! Thank you for the huge amount of research you did for this video.
Max Zulu
Max Zulu महीने पहले
Here cuz of nerd city. You got another subscriber
Eduardo Salazar
Eduardo Salazar महीने पहले
I just don’t go to trending
Black Monty Burns
Black Monty Burns महीने पहले
IN-vid trending is biased toward transsexual content. It's pretty damn obvious
Starfall 21X
Starfall 21X महीने पहले
The trending tab might as well not exist on my bar. I never click it.
180 Theory
180 Theory महीने पहले
This may have a lot to do with Google's overall focus on EAT. Traditional media would have a way higher EAT score in general. You might look into Google's search guidelines in general and that may give you a lot of insight. E.g. a game company will outrank a pewdiepie video. Likewise CNN vs secular talk.
truth Savage
truth Savage महीने पहले
So I am pretty sure that IN-vid sells spots on trending which is why we see so much artificial results.. They allow some organic spots but the vast majority are sold to traditional media
Russell Goradesky
Russell Goradesky महीने पहले
@ susan wojcicki
SpecialJ11 महीने पहले
Sweet, a quantitative representation of what's blindingly obvious. Media created by those who can make money not just on the media alone have a small portion of their revenue tied up in IN-vid views, and therefore do not care about paying off IN-vid to promote their content. They can afford their transaction with IN-vid to be a net loss because the platform for the viewing of their content by the younger generations is more valuable than whatever they could gain by playing the IN-vid game normally-playing the game like small creators have to because their budgets can't afford paid promotion on the scale of corporate media.
Sander Danly
Sander Danly 2 महीने पहले
If you work for IN-vid, your first incentive is to generate more viewership and business for the company. There are several causal implications from the observation that the "highest trenders" are overwhelmingly traditional media. The first, I like to call the "Alex Jones Inference", is that there is some social engineering aspect to what clearly is a manual selection of what constitutes trending videos. I don't totally dismiss this idea, yet there's no direct evidence for it so we can only suspect that it is the case. Another plausible incentive for IN-vid to manually fill their trending tab with conventional media would be as an incentive to generate interest/viewership from new users. Honestly, how many people who already watch videos on IN-vid go to the "trending" tab? I can say for sure that I've never once checked out the trending tab. If you already use IN-vid, and you're not a creator so you're not necessarily interested in who is "doing well", why would you go on the trending page? It seems possible to me that IN-vid created the trending tab as an "in" to people new to the platform - and just did a terrible job of naming the tab.
William Miller
William Miller 2 महीने पहले
Remember when Google's motto was "Don't Be Evil" ? Apparently they have forgotten.
Zzarcon1 2 महीने पहले
This is cause the US is authoritarian in the sense that they want corporations to run everything and dictate what we do.
Inculcated Frankenbean
Inculcated Frankenbean 2 महीने पहले
This is clearly ends justifying the means, which is the exact philosophy of the current far left ideologues who wish to determine what content we consume.
Psistorm Ikura
Psistorm Ikura 2 महीने पहले
Trending seems to be all about what moneyed interests want you to see, not what actually is trending currently by means of user interest. It's entirely manufactured trends, aka "we want you to consider this a popular video" even though it's not. Also why I /never/ look at trending.
funghoul 2 महीने पहले
Man Le
Man Le 2 महीने पहले
Traditional News Channels are a tool for the government manipulate how the general public think and feel. That’s why IN-vid pushing them on you. Alternative news are bad for the government. It’s all about control.
Rich Smith
Rich Smith 2 महीने पहले
PewDiePie gets a guranteed 5 mil + views every day, and he never gets on the main trending page. IN-vid is rigged.
Nicholas Jacob
Nicholas Jacob 2 महीने पहले
I am willing to bet this video never got on trending
Josip2811 2 महीने पहले
Well... this was recommended to me.. so..
Colorado Forest Beings
Colorado Forest Beings 2 महीने पहले
This is admitted by Susan W. No surprises but thank you for the hard work
Medicine of Sound
Medicine of Sound 2 महीने पहले
Isn't this censorship?! Does Joe Rogan know about this?! haha
Rahul Singhal
Rahul Singhal 2 महीने पहले
Creators made IN-vid to what it's today, IN-vid started destroying creators.
tempodude 2 महीने पहले
Before 9:47 : holy shit this video is amazing After 9:47 : LOOPDADDYYYY
Coffee Break - Puntata 18/11/2019
Mötley Crüe Is Back!
दृश्य 782 082
come here i have to tell you something
Zeds Dead - Coffee Break [HD]
Zeds Dead - Coffee Break
दृश्य 3
coffee break gold
दृश्य 90
CBS: Brazilian Grooves Vinyl Set
HOW TO SUCCEED....Coffee Break
The 108-Megapixel Smartphone Camera?!
दृश्य 2 220 820
Kanjoos Boyfriends 2 | Harshdeep Ahuja